Feed Like Fishes is Should’s first full-length record — an album of noisy, sedate, and minimal pop songs. Falling somewhere between shoegazer, slowcore, and postrock, Feed Like Fishes is a wonderfully complicated record that echoes the sounds of Yo La Tengo, Slowdive, Bedhead, and Galaxie 500. The album also includes Should’s take on The Wedding Present song “Spangle.”
The album begins with “Fish Fourteen,” a fuzzed-out lo-fi instrumental inspired by Colin Newman’s instrumental solo record, Provisionally Entitled The Singing Fish. “Sarah Missing” fits perfectly with the work on Should’s A Folding Sieve album, with its unforgettable vocal chorus awash in shoegazing delight.
“It Still Would” and “It’s Pull Is Slight” are moderately-paced indie rock tunes that bring to mind Bedhead, the latter song featuring a parade of bells throughout its extended coda.
“Memdrive” encircles whispered vocals with gliding bass and guitar lines in the spirit of Main’s early work. Should also explore Apollo-era Brian Eno on “Inst2” substituting heavy analog-delayed guitar notes for Eno’s keyboards.
“Both Eyes Open” ends the record with a nod to the melodious, delicate side of Yo La Tengo with Marc and Tanya’s coupled vocals going down as sweet as sugar.